Please be ready with your ID documents. Your payment is successful.
Super! Your ID is now verified.
Your payment was successful!
Your changes have been saved.
Super! Your ID is now verified. Please login to continue
There was an error processing your request. Please try again later.
Yes, this is how renters will reach out to you.
Your password is successfully updated. Thank you!

Houses For Rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY

We couldn’t find any rentals right now. Try searching nearby areas.

Create Match Alert
Get notified when your preferred rental is listed.
1/13
Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath

683 Richies Way

  • Guilford, CT
  • $2,350 ·
  • 1 Bed 1 Bath ·
  • Available now
Message sent
1/21
Entire Place 2Bed.1.5Bath Entire Place 2Bed.1.5Bath

32 Highland Avenue

  • Neptune Park ·
  • New London, CT
  • $2,500 ·
  • 2 Bed 1.5 Bath ·
  • Available now
Message sent
1/0

Undisclosed

  • Speonk, NY
  • $2,200 ·
  • 1 Bed 1 Bath ·
  • Available now
Message sent
1/11
Entire Place 3Bed.1Bath Entire Place 3Bed.1Bath

34 West End Drive

  • Hawks Nest Beach ·
  • Old Lyme, CT
  • $3,400 ·
  • 3 Bed 1 Bath ·
  • Available now
Message sent
1/0

108 Litton Avenue

  • Trails Corner ·
  • Groton, CT
  • $875 ·
  • 2 Bed 1 Bath ·
  • Available now
Message sent
1/1
Entire Place 2Bed.2Bath Entire Place 2Bed.2Bath

Dune Road

  • Westhampton, NY
  • $2,500 ·
  • 2 Bed 2 Bath ·
  • Available now
Message sent
1/0

169 Woodland Drive

  • Mohegan ·
  • Uncasville, CT
  • $1,800 ·
  • 2 Bed 2 Bath ·
  • Available now
Message sent
1/3
Entire Place 2Bed.3Bath Entire Place 2Bed.3Bath

97 West Main Street

  • Niantic, CT
  • $1,200 ·
  • 2 Bed 3 Bath ·
  • Available now
Message sent
1/6
Entire Place 4Bed.2Bath Entire Place 4Bed.2Bath

178 Beach Avenue

  • East Haven, CT
  • $2,800 ·
  • 4 Bed 2 Bath ·
  • Available now
Message sent
1/12
FRESH, CLEAN AND MODERN LOOK FRESH, CLEAN AND MODERN LOOK

4 Brocketts Point Road

  • Double Beach ·
  • Branford, CT
  • $4,000 ·
  • 3 Bed 2 Bath ·
  • Available now
Message sent
1/0

4 Brocketts Point Road

  • Double Beach ·
  • Branford, CT
  • $4,000 ·
  • 3 Bed 2 Bath ·
  • Available now
Message sent
1/0

41 Bel Aire Drive

  • Mystic Seaport ·
  • Groton, CT
  • $2,800 ·
  • 3 Bed 2 Bath ·
  • Available now
Message sent
1/1
Entire Place 3Bed.2Bath Entire Place 3Bed.2Bath

172 West Tiana Road

  • Hampton Bays, NY
  • $4,000 ·
  • 3 Bed 2 Bath ·
  • Available now
Message sent
1/0

6 East Street

  • Old Saybrook, CT
  • $3,500 ·
  • 2 Bed 2 Bath ·
  • Available now
Message sent
1/20
Entire Place 3Bed.2Bath Entire Place 3Bed.2Bath

Undisclosed

  • Jamesport, NY
  • $5,000 ·
  • 3 Bed 2 Bath ·
  • Available now
Message sent

Other Rental Property Types in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Your messages were sent!
You now have Cirtru Premium. Your messages were sent!