Please be ready with your ID documents. Your payment is successful.
Super! Your ID is now verified.
Your payment was successful!
Your changes have been saved.
Super! Your ID is now verified. Please login to continue
There was an error processing your request. Please try again later.
Yes, this is how renters will reach out to you.
Your password is successfully updated. Thank you!
Your password is successfully created. Thank you!
Your session has expired. Please login to continue.

Houses For Rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY

24 Houses for rent available in Shelter Island Heights, NY. Find or post a house.

We couldn’t find any rentals right now. Try searching nearby areas.

Create Match Alert
Get notified when your preferred rental is listed.
1/15
Entire Place 2Bed.1Bath Entire Place 2Bed.1Bath

123 George Street

  • Momauguin ·
  • East Haven, CT
  • $2,995 ·
  • 2 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/27
Entire Place 2Bed.1Bath Entire Place 2Bed.1Bath

55 Burr Street

  • East Shore ·
  • New Haven, CT
  • $2,550 ·
  • 2 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/29
Entire Place 4Bed.3.5Bath Entire Place 4Bed.3.5Bath

20 Infield Street

  • Reservoir ·
  • Bridgeport, CT
  • $10,000 ·
  • 4 Bed 3.5 Bath
Message sent
1/9
Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath

39 Langworthy Road

  • Langworthy Corner ·
  • Westerly, RI
  • $2,000 ·
  • 1 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/8
Entire Place 3Bed.1Bath Entire Place 3Bed.1Bath

8 Thomas Street

  • West Haven Center ·
  • West Haven, CT
  • $2,900 ·
  • 3 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/9
Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath

110 Benson Street

  • Brooklawn ·
  • Bridgeport, CT
  • $1,600 ·
  • 1 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/18
Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath

21 Colony Road

  • Seymour, CT
  • $2,000 ·
  • 1 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/0

361 Forest Lane

  • Smithtown, NY
  • $2,550 ·
  • 1 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/14
Entire Place 5Bed.2Bath Entire Place 5Bed.2Bath

330 Broadway

  • Hamden, CT
  • $4,200 ·
  • 5 Bed 2 Bath
Message sent
1/10
Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath

152 Temple Street

  • Chapel Street ·
  • New Haven, CT
  • $2,150 ·
  • 1 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/20
Entire Place 3Bed.1Bath Entire Place 3Bed.1Bath

23 Roarke Road

  • North Haven, CT
  • $3,000 ·
  • 3 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/13
Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath

103 Steinman Avenue

  • Westview Heights ·
  • Middlebury, CT
  • $1,850 ·
  • 1 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/10
Entire Place 4Bed.2.5Bath Entire Place 4Bed.2.5Bath

802 Evergreen Avenue

  • Hamden, CT
  • $5,500 ·
  • 4 Bed 2.5 Bath
Message sent
1/4
Entire Place 2Bed.2.5Bath Entire Place 2Bed.2.5Bath

160 Brittany Farms Road

  • New Britain, CT
  • $2,500 ·
  • 2 Bed 2.5 Bath
Message sent
1/2
Entire Place 3Bed.1Bath Entire Place 3Bed.1Bath

390 Swanson Avenue

  • Stratford, CT
  • $3,000 ·
  • 3 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/5
Entire Place 2Bed.1Bath Entire Place 2Bed.1Bath

203 Spring Avenue

  • Hill ·
  • New Haven, CT
  • $1,900 ·
  • 2 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/17
Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath

591 Gilbert Avenue

  • Hamden, CT
  • $2,000 ·
  • 1 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/16
Entire Place 3Bed.1.5Bath Entire Place 3Bed.1.5Bath

Nash Street

  • East Rock ·
  • New Haven, CT
  • $3,200 ·
  • 3 Bed 1.5 Bath
Message sent
1/1
Entire Place 2Bed.1Bath Entire Place 2Bed.1Bath

Stoneycrest Drive

  • Middletown, CT
  • $800 ·
  • 2 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/22
Entire Place 3Bed.1Bath Entire Place 3Bed.1Bath

24 Christian Street

  • Wallingford, CT
  • $3,275 ·
  • 3 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/13
Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath

683 Richies Way

  • Guilford, CT
  • $2,350 ·
  • 1 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/12
Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath Entire Place 1Bed.1Bath

215 Shingle Hill Road

  • West Shore ·
  • West Haven, CT
  • $1,700 ·
  • 1 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent
1/21
Entire Place 2Bed.1.5Bath Entire Place 2Bed.1.5Bath

32 Highland Avenue

  • Neptune Park ·
  • New London, CT
  • $2,500 ·
  • 2 Bed 1.5 Bath
Message sent
1/0

Undisclosed

  • Speonk, NY
  • $2,200 ·
  • 1 Bed 1 Bath
Message sent

Other Rental Property Types in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Rentals in Shelter Island Heights, NY
Rooms for Rent in Shelter Island Heights, NY
Your messages were sent!
You now have Cirtru Premium. Your messages were sent!